A book for the historian or the historically minded, Brenner Debate engages the differing perspectives on the Transition from Feudalism to Capitalism. Of especial interest is Bois's conclusion that capitalism began as a byproduct of XV Century Feudalism.
Text can be a little too heavy, and Brenner's 100-page "response" seems long, somewhat repetitious, and more than a little snarky.
Even still, a good book; I now know much more about this Transition and its features and facets
プライム無料体験をお試しいただけます
プライム無料体験で、この注文から無料配送特典をご利用いただけます。
非会員 | プライム会員 | |
---|---|---|
通常配送 | ¥410 - ¥450* | 無料 |
お急ぎ便 | ¥510 - ¥550 | |
お届け日時指定便 | ¥510 - ¥650 |
*Amazon.co.jp発送商品の注文額 ¥3,500以上は非会員も無料
無料体験はいつでもキャンセルできます。30日のプライム無料体験をぜひお試しください。
¥6,037¥6,037 税込
発送元: Amazon.co.jp 販売者: Amazon.co.jp
¥6,037¥6,037 税込
発送元: Amazon.co.jp
販売者: Amazon.co.jp
¥5,113¥5,113 税込
配送料 ¥257 6月17日-22日にお届け
発送元: thebookcommunity 販売者: thebookcommunity
¥5,113¥5,113 税込
配送料 ¥257 6月17日-22日にお届け
発送元: thebookcommunity
販売者: thebookcommunity
無料のKindleアプリをダウンロードして、スマートフォン、タブレット、またはコンピューターで今すぐKindle本を読むことができます。Kindleデバイスは必要ありません。
ウェブ版Kindleなら、お使いのブラウザですぐにお読みいただけます。
携帯電話のカメラを使用する - 以下のコードをスキャンし、Kindleアプリをダウンロードしてください。
The Brenner Debate: Agrarian Class Structure and Economic Development in Pre-Industrial Europe (Past and Present Publications) ペーパーバック – 1987/4/1
英語版
T. H. Aston
(編集),
C.H. E. Philpin
(Series Editor)
{"desktop_buybox_group_1":[{"displayPrice":"¥6,037","priceAmount":6037.00,"currencySymbol":"¥","integerValue":"6,037","decimalSeparator":null,"fractionalValue":null,"symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"pQA0tCpbItCniVOMN0WaWgfnQQqVaXwhEy6A7RnlqOgdvt3H%2Fg7ATgmT%2BbrUeLfO27ZVh46FIbs0BfUGsq1UyaSCux93MG76%2Fj1VisbobN882be9BZjhuAvQ8u%2FMqtkv","locale":"ja-JP","buyingOptionType":"NEW","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":0}, {"displayPrice":"¥5,113","priceAmount":5113.00,"currencySymbol":"¥","integerValue":"5,113","decimalSeparator":null,"fractionalValue":null,"symbolPosition":"left","hasSpace":false,"showFractionalPartIfEmpty":true,"offerListingId":"pQA0tCpbItCniVOMN0WaWgfnQQqVaXwhoWqEaiRNPldyVimiAyQmg0pl9EOdaCXF0lesRfIPy59gB1ZrwduBQCl3cqttxLsxK1WKMUNKbVbQ0l454Yfd0NtqQeZFZKtJLV3NxRQQgZm11uZM1lMcnuY4sIrwO9R64QMEEfTR1984TU1S21o0MA%3D%3D","locale":"ja-JP","buyingOptionType":"USED","aapiBuyingOptionIndex":1}]}
購入オプションとあわせ買い
Few historical issues have occasioned such discussion since at least the time of Marx as the transition from feudalism to capitalism in Western Europe. The Brenner Debate, which reprints from Past and Present various article in 1976, is a scholarly presentation of a variety of points of view, covering a very wide range in time, place and type of approach. Weighty theoretical responses to Brenner's first formulation followed from the late Sir Michael Postan, John Hatcher, Emmanuel Le Roy Ladurie and Guy Bois; more particular contributions came from Patricia Croot, David Parker, Arnost Klìma and Heide Wunder on England, France, Bohemia and Germany; and reflective pieces from R. H. Hilton and the late J. P. Cooper. Completing the volume, and giving it an overall coherence, are Brenner's own comprehensive response to those who had taken part in the debate, and also R. H. Hilton's introduction that aims to bring together the major themes in the collection of essays. The debate has already aroused widespread interest among historians and scholars in allied fields as well as among ordinary readers, and may reasonably be regarded as one of the most important historical debates of prevailing years.
- 本の長さ350ページ
- 言語英語
- 出版社Cambridge University Press
- 発売日1987/4/1
- 寸法13.79 x 2.24 x 21.59 cm
- ISBN-100521349338
- ISBN-13978-0521349338
商品の説明
レビュー
'In their brief editorial introduction to this volume, Aston and Philpin remark: 'The Brenner Debate … may justifiably lay claim to being one of the most important historical debates of topical years, and goes back, in one form or another, to at least the time of Marx'. The republication of the debate, as it appeared in the journal Past and Present from 1976 to 1982, together with a fresh, short introduction by Rodney Hilton, is therefore to be welcomed. For a debate as important and wide-ranging as this is, publication in one volume is vital.' Journal of Historical Geography
登録情報
- 出版社 : Cambridge University Press (1987/4/1)
- 発売日 : 1987/4/1
- 言語 : 英語
- ペーパーバック : 350ページ
- ISBN-10 : 0521349338
- ISBN-13 : 978-0521349338
- 寸法 : 13.79 x 2.24 x 21.59 cm
- Amazon 売れ筋ランキング: - 995,848位洋書 (洋書の売れ筋ランキングを見る)
- - 4,055位Economic History
- - 4,373位Accounting & Finance Economics
- - 27,233位European History (洋書)
- カスタマーレビュー:
カスタマーレビュー
星5つ中4.5つ
5つのうち4.5つ
全体的な星の数と星別のパーセンテージの内訳を計算するにあたり、単純平均は使用されていません。当システムでは、レビューがどの程度新しいか、レビュー担当者がAmazonで購入したかどうかなど、特定の要素をより重視しています。 詳細はこちら
15グローバルレーティング
虚偽のレビューは一切容認しません
私たちの目標は、すべてのレビューを信頼性の高い、有益なものにすることです。だからこそ、私たちはテクノロジーと人間の調査員の両方を活用して、お客様が偽のレビューを見る前にブロックしています。 詳細はこちら
コミュニティガイドラインに違反するAmazonアカウントはブロックされます。また、レビューを購入した出品者をブロックし、そのようなレビューを投稿した当事者に対して法的措置を取ります。 報告方法について学ぶ
他の国からのトップレビュー
Robert S Bogner
5つ星のうち4.0
For feudal scholars, not general readers
2020年2月1日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
This composite of essays covers a debate among medieval scholars concerning reasons why there was both a considerable delay and geographical variations in the transition between feudalism and capitalism. Much of it is written in hard to understand feudal English (and French). I found myself continually referring to my dictionary, which didn't always have the definitions. The book did not leave me with any clear cut answers, but, nonetheless, described in detail (too much detail, in my opinion) various paths from agrarian feudalism to agrarian capitalism...not mentioning much concerning the transition from feudal guilds to industrial capitalism.
A good read for scholars, but not lay people.
Bob Bogner
Author; Wilder: A Social Justice Phantasy
A good read for scholars, but not lay people.
Bob Bogner
Author; Wilder: A Social Justice Phantasy
Roberto
5つ星のうち3.0
Exactly what the title promises
2011年10月28日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
If you're interested in a formative debate on the key trends that led to the transition from a fundamentally feudal economy to one that was recognizably capitalist, this is your book. Essentially, the collection of articles constitutes an argument against the conventional wisdom at the time(that demographic declines and surges were the key drivers of change) by using examples that were similar in terms of population changes but resulted in radically different outcomes. This provides room for an analysis founded on the relationship to social class that local institutions had as the key driver in how that evolution to capitalism manifested.
It's problematic, as as many bold arguments are, in that it overemphasizes its own Big Idea not just against the existing orthodoxy but also presumes a great deal against other countercurrents (including ones not yet imagined when it was written) less founded in a Marxist analysis of historical cause and effect. But that's about the worst thing I can say about the content. In terms of readability it is a work that is condemned to be skimmed rather than read by all but the most dedicated readers, and that is unfortunately what relegates it to the status of background reference if you're interested in the field rather than something you would be likely to read in its own right or, god forbid, for pleasure.
It's problematic, as as many bold arguments are, in that it overemphasizes its own Big Idea not just against the existing orthodoxy but also presumes a great deal against other countercurrents (including ones not yet imagined when it was written) less founded in a Marxist analysis of historical cause and effect. But that's about the worst thing I can say about the content. In terms of readability it is a work that is condemned to be skimmed rather than read by all but the most dedicated readers, and that is unfortunately what relegates it to the status of background reference if you're interested in the field rather than something you would be likely to read in its own right or, god forbid, for pleasure.