James Scott: Complete Works 1903-1922
曲目リスト
ディスク: 1
1 | A Summer Breeze |
2 | The Fascinator |
3 | On The Pike |
4 | Frog Legs Rag |
5 | Kansas City Rag |
6 | My Girl From Anaconda |
7 | Grace And Beauty |
8 | Great Scott Rag |
9 | Valse Venice |
10 | The Ragtime "Betty" |
11 | Sunburst Rag |
12 | Sweetheart Rag |
13 | Hilarity Rag |
14 | Ophelia Rag |
15 | Hearts Longing |
16 | The Princess Rag |
17 | Quality Rag |
18 | Ragtime Oriole |
19 | The Suffragette |
ディスク: 2
1 | Climax Rag |
2 | Take Me Out To Lakeside |
3 | Evergreen Rag |
4 | Honeymoon Rag |
5 | Prosperity Rag |
6 | Efficiency Rag |
7 | Paramount Rag |
8 | Dixie Dimples |
9 | Rag Sentimental |
10 | Springtime Of Love |
11 | New Era Rag |
12 | Peace And Plenty Rag |
13 | Troubadour Rag |
14 | The Shimmie Shake |
15 | Modesty Rag |
16 | Pegasus |
17 | Don't Jazz Me Rag (I'm Music) |
18 | Victory Rag |
19 | Broadway Rag |
商品の説明
Amazonレビュー
Ragtime has its loyal fans but doesn't get much attention from most modern listeners. It's often thought of as the generic saloon music you hear in Westerns and other period movies. But ragtime was one of the building blocks of early jazz, and the form is far from artless. Composer, arranger, and pianist James Scott was born in 1885 in southwestern Missouri, a ragtime hotbed. This beautifully packaged, finely annotated double CD traces Scott's development as a composer of piano rags. The earliest pieces, "A Summer Breeze" and "The Fascinator," date from 1903 and show the influence of ragtime legend Scott Joplin on the then-18-year-old Scott. Just six years later, Scott wrote "Grace and Beauty," an elegant piece that demonstrates the young composer's strong command of structure. Later pieces show Scott subtly expanding the form. "Rag Sentimental" strikes the ear with its minor key sonorities, while the quirky "Pegasus" should do much to dispel the uninformed notion that all rags sound alike. Throughout the album, Dutch-born pianist Guido Nielsen brings his virtuoso talents to this jaunty and physically demanding music. The Complete Works is a must for ragtime collectors and an eye-opener for all kinds of music lovers. --Fred Cisterna
登録情報
- 製品サイズ : 14.58 x 0.99 x 12.75 cm; 119.92 g
- メーカー : Basta Records
- EAN : 0723724333628
- レーベル : Basta Records
- ASIN : B00005OW5Z
- ディスク枚数 : 2
- カスタマーレビュー:
他の国からのトップレビュー
Reading through the reviews of various ragtime recordings,
they seem to fall into one of two general categories.
Either:
1) "This guy races around all over the place,
adds too many embellishments, ignores the
composer's intent, and just doesn't
understand ragtime!"
or
2) "This guy slavishly sticks to the score like
it was Bach; has no feeling; no life; and
obviously he just doesn't understand ragtime!"
Well.
After years of studying, playing, composing, and performing ragtime one thing I can say is that ragtime is nothing if not flexible. It lends itself both to Joshua Rifkin-style classical interpretation, and to Dave Jason semi-improvisational interpretation. Neither approach is going to please everybody, and at some point you just have to draw the line, buy the recording, listen to the music, and decide for yourself.
The pieces on this recording are carefully and tastefully performed with, I believe, a serious and respectful desire to execute them as the composer intended. Tempos range from lively without being breakneck, to restrained without being somnolent (as a few of the Rifkin recordings are...) Phrasing flows with the rich melodic content, and supporting voices are clearly discernable.
Sure, a few of the tunes could have benefited from a more brisk, embellished treatment. But for a comprehensive first recording I personally feel that it's more important to get "what the composer said" out there, first. Once people have a chance to hear what the composer wrote, then they can take it and make new, more personally interpretive recordings as they deem appropriate.
If you're not familiar with the works of James Scott, this collection is as good an introduction as any. And if you are familiar with his work, this is a very handy package containing all of it (that we know of) on two disks. Here is music every bit as inventive as Joplin's, and yet very different in character. Mr. Nielsen clearly took the time to understand James Scott, and this recording will, I think, become a classic like the Rifkin recordings of Joplin.
Highly recommended.
The first thing that impressed me was how well Mr Neilsen achieves this important balance. The life force in Scott's music is evident in abundance but there is never any of the heavy-handed thumping sometimes brought to bear on these rags by technically good players. He varies the tempo interestingly from piece to piece and his accents catch the ear. The piano sound is full and clear but never overwhelms with a lot of noise and pedal, which fault is a sure way to kill Scott.
While the Scott rags are not really hard piano music in the strictly physical sense, they do have, in places, a certain mild awkwardness under the hand which is difficult to describe in words. To play them well it is necessary to accommodate this awkwardness musically and with rhythmic fluency; again, this is something Mr Neilsen does very well indeed.
The liner notes are among the best I have read for any CD, with copious and interesting discussion of each rag and of Scott's music and life.
Speaking as one who has played these pieces for many years, this CD gives me much to think about and learn from.
1) It covers all of Scott's compositions (at least the ones we know of, and that are completely by him).
2) The notes that come with the recording are very well done and interesting.
3) The discs themselves are quite attractive (much effort went into this whole endeavor to give it a complete and consistent look and feel).
4) The sound on the recordings is very good.
Now my qualms. I tend to agree with the review that felt Mr. Nielsen's range of expressiveness is too limited. After hearing these pieces played by others (recorded and live), it seems that the pianist here simply has come up with a rather rigid formula for interpreting Scott's rags (the songs and waltzes are allowed a bit more freedom). For some of these rags, this jaunty, rather chipper style works well. For others (I'm thinking particularly of the Troubadour Rag and "Modesty" here - both of which have received richer, more nuanced recordings elsewhere), it doesn't. While Scott is clearly not as varied and subtle a composer as Joplin or Lamb (there is no frequent thread of melancholy, striving for innovation, or a sense of the "outsider looking in" quality I find in much Joplin and some Lamb), his later works allow for much more variety of interpretation than we get here. Sometimes, especially on the second disc, it sounds uncomfortably like a player-piano.
So, I would recommend this to anyone wanting to learn more of the core Classic Ragtime literature, but I hope that other recordings will eventually be made to explore this repertoire from a slightly more nuanced perspective.