This is a book which paints a very black and white picture of the role of sweatshops, the effects of activism and regulation and the prospects for progress. It relies heavily on basic theories underpinning neoliberalism and supply-side economics, which in Powell's world are ironclad inviolable rules.
Powell's argument is simple: workers cannot earn more than the value of what they produce, and workers will choose the best option available to them. Those who campaign or criticise this are either economically illiterate activists or sneaky trade unions trying to stop jobs going to the Third World.
Unfortunately Powell never goes beyond simple free market arguments and despite at various points distancing himself from the simplicity of homo economicus, he makes plenty of unrealistic assumptions about competitive markets, information asymmetries, bargaining power, etc. He fails to explore complexities of development nor the potential of multilateral coordination, instead taking easy aim at campaigns that target indivdual companies or sweatshops.
There are undoubtedly concepts in this book that anti-sweatshop activists and others would benefit from learning, to ensure they appreciate the contexts and conditions within which sweatshops operate and avoid doing harm to the people they're trying to help. But I suspect they can find better and more thoughtful books out there on the subject than this one.
紙の本の価格: | ¥4,818 |
割引: | ¥ 154 (3%) |
| |
Kindle 価格: | ¥4,664 (税込) |
獲得ポイント: | 47ポイント (1%) |
続刊をお見逃しなく
シリーズ購読に登録する シリーズ購読について
購読は、シリーズの続刊を対象としています [1-Click® で今すぐシリーズ購読に登録する]にクリックすることで、AMAZON KINDLEストア利用規約に同意したものとみなされ、発売日にAmazonがお客様の選択した支払い方法、または登録されているその他の支払い方法に、予約注文受付期間中のAmazon.co.jpでの最低販売価格(予約注文受付期間なく販売される商品については、発売日の価格)(税込)を請求することに同意したものとみなされます。シリーズ購読はキャンセルされるまで、または連載が終了するまで継続されます。お客様はいつでも、アカウントサービスの「メンバーシップおよび購読 」からシリーズ購読をキャンセルすることができます。
購読は、シリーズの続刊を対象としています
1-Click®でシリーズ購読に登録する
最新刊の発売日に配信されます
どの商品を購入することになりますか?
[シリーズ購読]は連載中のシリーズで今後発売される続刊を対象としています。ご登録いただいた時点で既に発売開始している商品はシリーズ購読に登録しても自動配信の対象とはなりません。また、本シリーズ購読は、一話毎に販売している商品は対象としておりません。
続刊の価格はどうやってわかりますか?
予約注文ができるようになると同時に価格が設定されます。予約商品の価格保証が適用される商品は、予約注文受付期間中のAmazon.co.jpでの最低販売価格[ (税込)が適用されます]。なお、予約注文受付期間なく販売される商品については、発売と同時に価格が設定されます。続刊以降の価格、および、お客様がシリーズ購読をキャンセルまたは連載が終了するまでにお客様にお支払いいただく総額については、事前に確定することができません。続刊以降の価格は、確定し次第、メールにてご案内いたします。
シリーズ購読はいつまで続きますか?
シリーズ購読は、お客様がシリーズ購読をキャンセルするまで、連載が終了するまで、またはシリーズ購読のサービス提供終了まで継続します。予約注文またはシリーズ購読はいつでもキャンセルできます。
各商品の購入代金の請求はいつですか?
代金の請求は商品が発売され、ダウンロード可能になるまで行われません。また、代金の請求はお客様の選択した支払い方法、または登録されているその他の支払い方法により、自動的に行います。代金の請求日、すなわち商品の発売日は、事前に確定することができません。確定し次第、メールにてご案内いたします。
[シリーズ購読]は連載中のシリーズで今後発売される続刊を対象としています。ご登録いただいた時点で既に発売開始している商品はシリーズ購読に登録しても自動配信の対象とはなりません。また、本シリーズ購読は、一話毎に販売している商品は対象としておりません。
続刊の価格はどうやってわかりますか?
予約注文ができるようになると同時に価格が設定されます。予約商品の価格保証が適用される商品は、予約注文受付期間中のAmazon.co.jpでの最低販売価格[ (税込)が適用されます]。なお、予約注文受付期間なく販売される商品については、発売と同時に価格が設定されます。続刊以降の価格、および、お客様がシリーズ購読をキャンセルまたは連載が終了するまでにお客様にお支払いいただく総額については、事前に確定することができません。続刊以降の価格は、確定し次第、メールにてご案内いたします。
シリーズ購読はいつまで続きますか?
シリーズ購読は、お客様がシリーズ購読をキャンセルするまで、連載が終了するまで、またはシリーズ購読のサービス提供終了まで継続します。予約注文またはシリーズ購読はいつでもキャンセルできます。
各商品の購入代金の請求はいつですか?
代金の請求は商品が発売され、ダウンロード可能になるまで行われません。また、代金の請求はお客様の選択した支払い方法、または登録されているその他の支払い方法により、自動的に行います。代金の請求日、すなわち商品の発売日は、事前に確定することができません。確定し次第、メールにてご案内いたします。
Cambridge Studies in Economics, Choice, and Society を購読しました。 続刊の配信が可能になってから24時間以内に予約注文します。最新刊がリリースされると、予約注文期間中に利用可能な最低価格がデフォルトで設定している支払い方法に請求されます。
「メンバーシップおよび購読」で、支払い方法や端末の更新、続刊のスキップやキャンセルができます。
エラーが発生しました。 エラーのため、お客様の定期購読を処理できませんでした。更新してもう一度やり直してください。
無料のKindleアプリをダウンロードして、スマートフォン、タブレット、またはコンピューターで今すぐKindle本を読むことができます。Kindleデバイスは必要ありません。
ウェブ版Kindleなら、お使いのブラウザですぐにお読みいただけます。
携帯電話のカメラを使用する - 以下のコードをスキャンし、Kindleアプリをダウンロードしてください。
Out of Poverty: Sweatshops in the Global Economy (Cambridge Studies in Economics, Choice, and Society) (English Edition) Kindle版
This book provides a comprehensive defense of third-world sweatshops. It explains how these sweatshops provide the best available opportunity to workers and how they play an important role in the process of development that eventually leads to better wages and working conditions. Using economic theory, the author argues that much of what the anti-sweatshop movement has agitated for would actually harm the very workers they intend to help by creating less desirable alternatives and undermining the process of development. Nowhere does this book put 'profits' or 'economic efficiency' above people. Improving the welfare of poorer citizens of third world countries is the goal, and the book explores which methods best achieve that goal. Out of Poverty will help readers understand how activists and policy makers can help third world workers.
- 言語英語
- 出版社Cambridge University Press
- 発売日2014/3/10
- ファイルサイズ2012 KB
Amazon スマイルSALE 開催中
期間限定!人気商品がお買い得。ポイントアップキャンペーン実施中
Amazon スマイルSALE を今すぐチェック
Amazon スマイルSALE を今すぐチェック
まとめ買い
シリーズの詳細を見る-
最初の3冊¥ 14,005141pt (1%)
-
最初の5冊¥ 24,393245pt (1%)
-
最初の10冊¥ 49,710498pt (1%)
-
23冊すべて¥ 160,2491603pt (1%)
まとめ買い
このシリーズは全23冊です。
-
最初の3冊¥ 14,005141pt (1%)
-
最初の5冊¥ 24,393245pt (1%)
-
最初の10冊¥ 49,710498pt (1%)
-
23冊すべて¥ 160,2491603pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
141pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
245pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
498pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
1603pt (1%)
上のボタンを押すと注文が確定し、Kindleストア利用規約に同意したものとみなされます。支払方法及び返品等についてはこちら。
このまとめ買いには3冊が含まれます。
このまとめ買いには5冊が含まれます。
このまとめ買いには10冊が含まれます。
このまとめ買いには1-23冊のうち23冊が含まれます。
エラーが発生しました。
獲得ポイント:
141pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
245pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
498pt (1%)
獲得ポイント:
1603pt (1%)
上のボタンを押すと注文が確定し、Kindleストア利用規約に同意したものとみなされます。支払方法及び返品等についてはこちら。
商品の説明
レビュー
'The term 'sweatshops' is a dirty word to students on American campuses and activists around the world, implying exploited workers toiling in horrible conditions for long hours at low pay. Powell's splendid new book gives us another perspective: how workers view sweatshops as an opportunity for improving their economic condition. Indeed, countless Americans, Japanese, and others enjoy their high standard of today living because their grandmothers and grandfathers worked in sweatshops a century ago.' Douglas Irwin, Dartmouth College, and author of Free Trade Under Fire
'This eloquent book makes the compassionate case for sweatshops in poor countries as what poor workers voluntarily select as employers because they are better than the alternatives. It is uncommonly clear in this book that the economists' case for sweatshops is based on what's best for the workers, not what's best for efficiency or profits or First World consumers.' William Easterly, Co-Director, Development Research Institute, New York University, and author of The White Man's Burden and The Elusive Quest for Growth
'Ben Powell has written a brilliant and thought-provoking book on sweatshops. He challenges a number of critical beliefs about them which, although springing from concern about the poor, lead to policies that will harm the poor. No policymakers, especially in aid and development agencies like USAID and UNDP, can afford to ignore this masterly book.' Jagdish Bhagwati, Columbia University, and author of In Defense of Globalization
'This eloquent book makes the compassionate case for sweatshops in poor countries as what poor workers voluntarily select as employers because they are better than the alternatives. It is uncommonly clear in this book that the economists' case for sweatshops is based on what's best for the workers, not what's best for efficiency or profits or First World consumers.' William Easterly, Co-Director, Development Research Institute, New York University, and author of The White Man's Burden and The Elusive Quest for Growth
'Ben Powell has written a brilliant and thought-provoking book on sweatshops. He challenges a number of critical beliefs about them which, although springing from concern about the poor, lead to policies that will harm the poor. No policymakers, especially in aid and development agencies like USAID and UNDP, can afford to ignore this masterly book.' Jagdish Bhagwati, Columbia University, and author of In Defense of Globalization
著者について
Benjamin Powell is the Director of the Free Market Institute at Texas Tech University and a Visiting Professor in the Rawls College of Business. He is a Past President of the Association of Private Enterprise Education and a Senior Fellow with the Independent Institute. Professor Powell is editor of Making Poor Nations Rich: Entrepreneurship and the Process of Development (2008) and co-editor of Housing America: Building Out of a Crisis (2009). He is author of more than 50 scholarly articles and policy studies. His primary fields of research are economic development, Austrian economics, and public choice. Dr Powell's scholarly research on sweatshops has been published in Comparative Economic Studies, the Journal of Labor Research, Human Rights Quarterly, and the Journal of Business Ethics. His research findings have been reported in more than 100 popular press outlets including the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times. He received his PhD in economics from George Mason University.
登録情報
- ASIN : B00J8LQG6Y
- 出版社 : Cambridge University Press (2014/3/10)
- 発売日 : 2014/3/10
- 言語 : 英語
- ファイルサイズ : 2012 KB
- 同時に利用できる端末数 : 出版社からの制限により、この本を同時に読める端末数は最大4台までとなります
- Text-to-Speech(テキスト読み上げ機能) : 有効
- X-Ray : 有効にされていません
- Word Wise : 有効
- 付箋メモ : Kindle Scribeで
- 本の長さ : 197ページ
- カスタマーレビュー:
著者について
著者をフォローして、新作のアップデートや改善されたおすすめを入手してください。
著者の本をもっと発見したり、よく似た著者を見つけたり、著者のブログを読んだりしましょう
他の国からのトップレビュー
Emmet McNamee
5つ星のうち2.0
Oversimplistic and hgihly ideological
2020年9月16日に英国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
Cashew Son
5つ星のうち5.0
Want to Help the World’s Poor? Allow Them a Way Out
2018年11月4日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
If you care about global poverty and are open-minded, then this is a must read. The arguments make perfect sense and are backed by hard data, including surveys of the workers.
Both sweatshop proponents and critics have the same end in mind – the raising of living standards, better working conditions, and a reduction in poverty. The difference is that critics generally operate on the surface level and favor short-term ‘solutions’ that feel good, but do more harm to the people they purport to help – and can even impede the economic progress of an entire country.
As Powell points out, economic development is happening at a faster pace, meaning that it does not take as long for a country to see a dramatic increase in living standards as it once did – as long as the process is allowed to develop naturally. Artificial measures, such as regulations that set back economic freedom, do more harm than good. Eventually they would become superfluous anyway, as happened in the West.
It does no good to pretend that proponents of sweatshops are evil people unconcerned with the welfare of workers. The reality is that they have simply thought deeper about the issue, know what works, and have the courage to say so.
Both sweatshop proponents and critics have the same end in mind – the raising of living standards, better working conditions, and a reduction in poverty. The difference is that critics generally operate on the surface level and favor short-term ‘solutions’ that feel good, but do more harm to the people they purport to help – and can even impede the economic progress of an entire country.
As Powell points out, economic development is happening at a faster pace, meaning that it does not take as long for a country to see a dramatic increase in living standards as it once did – as long as the process is allowed to develop naturally. Artificial measures, such as regulations that set back economic freedom, do more harm than good. Eventually they would become superfluous anyway, as happened in the West.
It does no good to pretend that proponents of sweatshops are evil people unconcerned with the welfare of workers. The reality is that they have simply thought deeper about the issue, know what works, and have the courage to say so.
Gregory F. Rehmke
5つ星のうち5.0
Sweatshops are an imperfect path out of poverty for the developing world.
2014年4月23日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
Elizabeth Gaskell's "North and South" (both book and BBC miniseries) brings to life the challenges and opportunities of England's 19th century sweatshops. Ben Powell's Out of Poverty examines today's textile factories in the developing world and their role as a pathway out of poverty. Migrants from rural villages only gradually acquire skills valuable in modern factories. But as poor people learn how to work with textile and other light industry machinery, their earning power and wages rise. Critics of sweatshops wish there was a better, faster way, wish wages and working conditions could be better faster. Ben Powell is a critic of sweatshop critics, and he examines the many claimed shortcuts to prosperity that wishful thinkers say should be adopted (and mandated if not adopted voluntarily). These alleged shortcuts turn out to cause long delays. Ideally, the unskilled of the developing world could migrate to better-paying jobs. And ideally machinery and infrastructure could more quickly "migrate" to developing countries. Sweatshops are a compromise in today's imperfect world that lacks the freedom of movement and investment taken for granted in the decades before World War I.
Benjamin Cliff
5つ星のうち5.0
This is an excellent book for people that are serious about helping those ...
2014年8月25日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
This is an excellent book for people that are serious about helping those in 3rd world nations, and not merely feeling better about themselves. This seems harsh, but as someone that has worked with a non-profit this seems to be how many people make charity donation decisions.
If economics is the dismal science this book gets to the heart of it: the limitation of natural and unnatural scarcity by conditions outside of our direct control. Empirical research into these areas exposes us to the rampant poverty they many are very conformable not knowing about. But realism is necessary to those that wish to make improvements to the world.
The economic analysis is sharp and nuanced, it is not generalized. It does not overstate and say what can not be said without complete accuracy.
This book is short and concise and could be beneficial to both to critics and advocates of free markets. It is careful to explain why and how things work even to the point of getting into the intrinsic ways markets work and coordinate.
If economics is the dismal science this book gets to the heart of it: the limitation of natural and unnatural scarcity by conditions outside of our direct control. Empirical research into these areas exposes us to the rampant poverty they many are very conformable not knowing about. But realism is necessary to those that wish to make improvements to the world.
The economic analysis is sharp and nuanced, it is not generalized. It does not overstate and say what can not be said without complete accuracy.
This book is short and concise and could be beneficial to both to critics and advocates of free markets. It is careful to explain why and how things work even to the point of getting into the intrinsic ways markets work and coordinate.
Rosolino Candela
5つ星のうち5.0
Excellent Assessment of the Role of Sweatshops for Alleviating Poverty in the Developing World!
2014年4月26日にアメリカ合衆国でレビュー済みAmazonで購入
Dr. Powell's book provides a concise, yet thorough, understanding of the role sweatshops play in alleviating poverty in the developing world. Grounded in basic economic theory, Powell analyzes how sweatshops provide the best available alternative for the poorest of the developing world. Although economics is the basis of analysis, Powell's defense of sweatshops is not justified not by economic efficiency or corporate profits. If the goal of economic growth is to alleviate the poverty of the poorest individuals in the worlds, sweatshops must be considered as one of the methods by which to achieve that goal. Attempts by individuals in developed countries to protest sweatshops, which are part of a broader process of economic development, has unintended consequences that harm the poorest people. Dr. Powell's masterful exposition of sweatshops as a means by which to improve the economic welfare of the Third World appeals not only to professional economists, sociologists, philosophers, and political scientists, but also to the interested layman as well!